Our Team
Agents & Staff
Carol began her career as a buyer of women’s clothing for Vogue Stores, The Body Shop, and Bealls. After retiring from retail, she opened a liquor store and gas station in Oxford, Maryland, on the Eastern Shore, where she quickly became a local favorite for selling bait and the community’s favorite items.
Never one to slow down, Carol later opened a seven-day-a-week breakfast, lunch, and dinner restaurant called The Chatterbox, known for its generous portions and great taste—another local favorite.
Eventually, Carol returned to St. Augustine, where she lived along the St. Johns River with her parents. Real estate had always been part of Carol’s life, and she became licensed at age 58—and she’s still going strong today.
Carol built a reputation for listing and selling the off-the-beaten-path river properties when no one else would. Around here, she’s known as the “River Queen.”
904.477.4280
cdr4@bellsouth.net
Colleen worked in New York for Liz Claiborne and traveled throughout the Orient with the production team. She later moved to Los Angeles, where she appeared as a background actor in several 1990s sitcoms, often alongside her pets and classic cars. Following in her mother’s footsteps in the real estate business, Colleen eventually moved back to St. Augustine. There, she raised her daughter through the St. Johns County school system and helped prepare her for college at Stetson University.
615.866.8687
tiffany.mees@outlook.com
With over 11 years of dedicated experience in the real estate industry, I proudly hold my real estate license in Tennessee, while residing near Fort Campbell. My expertise primarily lies in helping VA buyers, first-time homebuyers, and specializing in relocation as well as new construction. Many clients have purchased homes from me site unseen.
I have achieved a sales volume exceeding 35 homes in several years of my real estate career, showcasing my ability to excel in a high-volume environment.
My passion for new construction projects compliments my commitment to assisting clients in finding their dream homes. I believe in building lasting relationships through honesty, transparency, and a forthcoming attitude, which many clients have come to appreciate.
Having graduated from St. Augustine High with class of 1998 and holding property near the beach in the Saint Augustine and Nocatee areas, I am excited to expand my real estate endeavors in this beautiful region. My local knowledge, coupled with my unwavering dedication to client satisfaction, positions me to provide unparalleled service to those looking to buy or sell in this market.
Reasons to Choose Lighthouse Realty
There’s always a way to buy and sell your home that works for you.
Expect open, honest communication every step of the way.
We’ve helped countless families in the many years we’ve been in business.
Testimonials
"Fantastic service from the whole team but especially Margie Lindsey - we love her! It's a comfort knowing Margie is not only professional but also knowledgeable and a person of high integrity. Can't speak highly enough! This review is a bit overdue but over the years she's always been so patient, resourceful and amazing to work with. We really appreciate her and the whole Lighthouse team. Everyone in the office is polite and accommodating - they will go out of their way to solve any issues that come up and treat you like family. Lots of integrity and St. Augustine hospitality at its finest - thanks Lighthouse Realty!"
We are so impressed that I am now writing this review — a first for me. They are among the best we have worked with. We never have to wait for return phone calls.
We cannot say enough about Lighthouse Realty and it is all good! If you are buying or selling a home, make sure you use Lighthouse Realty. You will not go wrong!
Very easy to work with. I get a call right away when there is a showing and I get a call with the feedback, which in most cases is not provided.